Audit Firm: Audit Quality Indicators

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) is a nonprofit corporation in USA established by Congress to oversee the audits of public companies in order to protect investors and the public interest by promoting informative, accurate, and independent audit reports. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, which created the PCAOB, required that auditors of U.S. public companies be subject to external and independent oversight.

The PCAOB has recently issued a concept release on Audit Quality Indicators (AQI). It has sought the public comment on the content and possible uses of a group of potential "audit quality indicators." The indicators are a potential portfolio of quantitative measures that may provide new insights about how to evaluate the quality of audits and how high quality audits are achieved.

The 28 potential Audit Quality Indicators are:

AUDIT PROFESSIONALS

Availability	Competence	Focus
1. Staffing Leverage 2.Partner Workload 3.Manager and Staff Workload 4.Technical Accounting and Auditing Resources 5.Persons with Specialized Skill and Knowledge	6.Experience of Audit Personnel 7.Industry Expertise of Audit Personnel 8.Turnoverof Audit Personnel 9.Amount of Audit Work Centralized at Service Centers10.Training Hours per Audit Professional	11.Audit Hours and Risk Areas 12.Allocation of Audit Hours to Phases of the Audit

AUDIT PROCESS

Tone at the Top and Leadership	Incentives	Independence	Infrastructure	Monitoring and Remediation
13.Results of Independent Survey of Firm Personnel	14.Quality Ratings and Compensation 15.Audit Fees, Effort, and Client Risk	16.Compliance with Independence Requirement	17.Investment in Infrastructure Supporting Quality Auditing	18.Audit Firms' Internal Quality Review Results 19.PCAOB Inspection Results 20.Technical Competency Testing

AUDIT RESULTS

Financial Statements	Internal Control	Going Concern	Communication between Auditors and Audit Committee	Enforcement and Litigation
21. Frequency and Impact of Financial Statement Restatements for Errors 22.Fraud and other Financial Reporting Misconduct 23.Inferring Audit Quality from Measures of Financial Reporting Quality	24.Timely Reporting of Internal Control Weaknesses	25.Timely Reporting of Going Concern Issues	26.Results of Independent Surveys of Audit Committee Members	27. Trends in PCAOB and SEC Enforcement Proceedings 28.Trends in Private Litigation

Additional Thoughts

Quality control for audit is very important as only with an effective Quality control mechanism, the public interest can be served through independence, integrity, ethics, objectivity and quality performance. The aforementioned quality indicators can prove to be a useful benchmark for auditors to gauge their performance.

Some Colour to Fraud Investigation

Lisa Weaver, the examiner of P7, wrote the article about forensic auditing in Student Accountant in 2008. I can not say it is the most jolly reading in the world, but I still  recommend it to all accountancy students for effective preparation to exam or job interview in forensic department.

In fact the fraud is highly tested area in all accountancy certification exams, in  ACCA (F8, P1,P7) and US CPA. I would like to add some “colour” to the considerations about fraud investigation engagements.

Types of Fraud

Ms Weaver kindly mentioned for us that there are three types of fraud:

·        corruption,

·        asset misappropriation,

·        financial statements fraud.

According to PwC’s report “Global Economic Crime Survey” her statement is very close to reality. I highly recommend to read that report, because it is quite interesting and practical product. PwC gives a table of the most popular economic crimes, which is in line with Weaver’s article:

Lets dive in financial statement fraud.

Financial Statement Fraud

Elliot and Elliot in their book state that inventory valuation gives lots of opportunities for creative accounting. Inferring from Treadway Comission Report they consider that ‘fraud often involved overstatement of revenues and assets with inventory fraud’ featuring understating bad debt allowances, overstating value of inventory. There are several groups of inventory related fraud: year-end manipulations, purchases not recorded (cut-off issues), fictitious transfers of non-existent inventory, carrying obsolete inventory at a cost, reducing cost of goods sold by adjusting journal entries.

Fraud and Bankruptcies

Gaughan, referring to Dun & Bradstreet research, noted than in 2000s number of bankruptcies related with fraud significantly increased. WorldCom, Enron, Adelfia, Refco, Parmalat were ‘brought down by management fraud’. He also mentioned BancruptcyData.com table of the largest bankruptcies. I have found it’s updated version since he has written his book, here it is:

As we already know accounting fraud (so called, ‘Repo 105’) was also involved in Lehman’s case. Though it was not the primary reason for their collapse, but still conceal of fraud contributed to the overall situation. This is how Sikka describes this case in his article:

‘Lehman’s own accounting personnel described Repo 105 transactions as an “accounting gimmick” and a “lazy way of managing the balance sheet as opposed to legitimately meeting balance sheet targets at quarter end”, but the bank received a clean bill of health from auditors Ernst & Young. The insolvency examiner was critical of auditors and protracted litigation will follow.’

By The Way

There is a special certification of specialists in fraud investigations which is carried out by Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. CFEs are the guys, just like us, accountants J However, additionally to common accountancy subjects they study things as criminology and have special training to present evidence in court.

By the way, have you ever been involved in fraud investigations or may be you performed fraud investigation procedures within audit engagements? Please share information. 

References

Elliot, B. and Elliot, J. (2007). Financial Accounting and Reporting. 11^th Edition. Pearson Education Ltd.

BankruptcyData.com (2010). Site Link:

 http://www.bankruptcydata.com/Research/Largest_Overall_All-Time.pdf

Gaughan, P.A. (2007). Mergers, Acquisitions and Corporate Restructurings. Forth Edition. John Wiley and Sons Inc.

PwC. (2009) Global Economic Crime Survey: Economic Crime in a Downturn. November 2009, PwC

Sikka, P. (2011).The EU man cometh. PQ Magazine. No. 1, p. 27.

Weaver, L. (2008). Forensic Auditing. Student Accountant. September 2008, p. 58-60.